null 2010M 1 null null null null null null null null null null v ( S ) null null null null null null null null null null Jan., 2010 33 null 1 null null null null JournalofShanxiUniversity(Philosophy& SocialScience) null null null null Vo.l 33null No. 1null null风险社会中的专家体制:困境与出路李艳红1,张培富2(1.2 7 v 6 5 ,? 300071;+ Y Y i ,? 300161;2. v S / , 030006)K null 1 : B ,1 p Q E 8 % B # ? 3 b E 8 1 C S E y V s ,y N ,V , E 8 K r i G % Z , B b!1 u s B : B / B b . d : E 8 C E 8 i B c bB Z , S / ? Z a M ,P 8 Y b V a $ a m I n a m $ i i j ,B %119 33 null 1 null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null null , : B E 8 : M m ! Z 7 b f / , P % E ,9 i V r b A M 1 m 8 by N ,% V C G bV B i l ,V % B B , E 8 b null ( : E 8 ; E 8 d 1 % 8 Q ,* , | a T L C E 8 r s A 1 b r , E p g ,7 O S E 4 4 z ? b C % B ,A V M E 8 m , x A . r ? W 7 ; (5) V ? S A r B ,L C 1 E 1 b V r M _ C a ,S E l V S K g # P ? , v % 8 % , 8 . E = i V r , Y % ? b E 8 d ,A T S / Y bM C v 3 B ,% ? % 5 ? i ,B F E 8 % T # by N , S E 8 7 ,% S ? Z 1 o 5 bV % E 8 ? , V Z :B Z ,9 e W M . ,r .2 : , 2001.4 : null X , D null , S + null I .1 Q C C a. d M.u ,r . : 6 , 2001.5 i null . S M. 珺珺,等译.长沙:湖南 , 1988: 109. 6CollinsHM, EvansR. TheThirdWaveofScience Studies:StudiesofExpertise and Experience J. SocialStudies ofScience, 2002, 32(2): 240- 241.7BrainL. Campbel.l Uncertainty asSymbolicAction in DisnullputesamongExpertsJ. SocialStudiesofScience, 1985, 15(3): 448.8Harvey Brooks, Chester L Cooper, eds. Science for PublicPolicyM. Oxford: PergamonPress, 1986.9M iguelA. Centeno, Patricio Silva. The PoliticsofExpertiseinLatinAmericaM. London:MacmillanPress, 1998.10 : null X . B M . p ,r .2 :r , 2004.11 . M. : S v , 2005: 61- 62.12 M : null ) .C S E V M .u ,r . : S M , 2004:r .13 , . B y M. : S , 2006: 45.14 D null . M. null B , null ,r . : , 1989: 290.15 JasanoffS. Contested boundaries in policy- relevant scinullenceJ. SocialStudiesofScience, 1987(17): 195- 230.16Alan Irwin. ThePoliticsofTalk: Coming toTermswiththe%New& ScientificGovernance J. Social Studies ofScinullence, 2006, 36(2): 299- 320.17 null .% S 8 B 1 5 N. , 1986- 07- 31(4).Expert System in the Risk Society: Dilemma andWayOutLIYan- hong1, ZHANG P